Three big oil marketing companies in Nigeria—AYM Shafa Limited, A. A. Rano Limited, and Matrix Petroleum Services Limited—have made a defense against a lawsuit filed by Dangote Petroleum Refinery and Petrochemicals FZE, which wants to control all of Nigeria’s oil business. The marketers say that allowing Dangote’s request would have a huge impact on the country’s energy situation, mainly by making it harder for competitors to operate and putting energy security at risk.
The Nigeria Midstream and Downstream Petroleum Regulatory Authority (NMDPRA) gave these marketers licenses to bring refined petroleum products into Nigeria. These licenses are at the heart of the disagreement. Dangote Refinery says that these licenses were given out wrongly, even though it says that its refinery can make enough jet fuel and automotive gas oil (AGO) to meet local demand. The company has said that these trade licenses shouldn’t have been given to other companies because it doesn’t need them to make more products.
Marketers, on the other hand, say that Dangote’s refinery doesn’t yet make enough refined goods for Nigeria, which has more than 200 million people, to meet its daily needs. They stress that even though Dangote Refinery has made a lot of progress in processing, its output is still not high enough to meet the whole country’s needs for gasoline, jet fuel, and diesel. They say that this shortfall is why they should be allowed to bring in refined goods to make sure that the country’s energy needs are always met.
Marketers say that giving Dangote a monopoly in the oil business would be very bad for Nigeria’s economy and energy security. They say that this would mean no more competition in the market, which could make fuel prices go up and leave the country open to supply problems. A single company that controls the supply of oil goods could set prices, which could mean big price increases for consumers. Also, if there is a technical problem or something else that stops Dangote Refinery from working, Nigeria would not have a backup plan for making sure there is enough fuel because the country does not have enough storage space to meet the short-term shortage.
Another big worry that the traders have is what a monopolized oil sector would mean for Nigeria’s economy as a whole. They say that if Nigeria put all of its oil “eggs in one basket,” it would put its energy security at risk. Nigeria would have a serious oil crisis if Dangote Refinery, which is the only plant that makes refined products, had any problems, whether they were technical, financial, or something else. Because the country only has one refinery, it might be vulnerable to supply shocks like those that happen in other parts of the world, especially in places where most of the oil refineries are in one company or area.
Additionally, the marketers say they have followed all the laws that apply, such as the Petroleum Industry Act (PIA), which controls the giving out of licenses to import petroleum goods. It is their claim that the NMDPRA legally gave them their licenses and that there is no proof that these licenses have hurt Dangote’s business. In fact, the marketers say that their businesses work well with Dangote’s refinery because they make sure that there is a steady flow of oil products while Dangote’s refinery increases production.
The traders also say that the import licenses are very important for keeping Nigeria’s oil industry stable. If Nigeria couldn’t bring in refined goods from other countries, it would have to get all of its refined oil from Dangote Refinery. They say that this concentration of supply is not only risky but also goes against the rules of a competitive market, which says that many players should add to supply to keep things fair and stable. The market can keep prices cheap and give customers better service because of competition. This would not be possible with a monopoly.
These marketers also say that the licenses that allow them to bring in refined goods don’t hurt Dangote’s refinery and don’t violate the company’s rights or interests. In their defense, they say that competition isn’t hurting the refinery’s business and that they are following the law, which makes the country’s energy security stronger instead of weaker. They also say that a monopolistic approach would undo the progress Nigeria has made in making its oil business more competitive and strong.
When the court rules in favor of Dangote Refinery’s lawsuit, other companies could lose their import licenses. This would make Dangote the only company in Nigeria that can make and sell refined oil goods. This would put all of Nigeria’s energy pricing and security in the hands of a single company, leaving the country open to supply problems or price increases.
Because the case is still going on, the court has put it off until January 20, 2025. This will give both sides time to think about whether they can reach a solution without going to court. Dangote Refinery has said it is ready to drop its lawsuit, but only if certain conditions are met. It is still not clear if a solution can be found outside of court. The case’s outcome could have big effects on the structure of Nigeria’s oil business, which could have effects on energy policy, competition, and prices in the country’s fuel markets.
ALSO READ:
